Shocked by sight, Mueller walked into the living room to show the Polaroids to his partner, uttering the words, "These are for real.". (People v. Carlson (1980), 79 Ill. 2d 564, 580, quoting People v. Ward (1975), 61 Ill. 2d 559, 568.) (Witherspoon v. Illinois (1968), 391 U.S. 510, 20 L. Ed. He said, "You're just in time for the late show" and turned on a projector and showed a "gay" pornographic film on the wall of the room. We have reviewed the other portions of the record cited by defendant in support of his argument that the circuit court's questioning was insufficient. They had no clue of how to treat a gay rape of any sort and did not even think that would be possible.. [1][2], Rignall identified as bisexual and lived with his girlfriend as well as partner Ron Wilder, described by Rignall's attorney Fred R. Richman as a "live-in companion". Worked at Pilkington. 9-1(d); see Liptak v. Security Benefit Association (1932), 350 Ill. Acknowledging that the People would have to call these newsmen on rebuttal, and that there might be some problem with "the newsmen privilege," the court ruled: "I feel that it is on such an insignificant point that it would not be worth the legal ramifications of attempting to put in that rebuttal, so I would instruct the State not to put in that rebuttal, and I will instruct the jury to disregard anything regarding that." While defendant has a fundamental right to be present at any critical stage of the proceedings against him, he does not have an absolute right to be present also at the argument of motions subsequent to verdict. While defendant has attempted to distinguish Kubat by arguing that the *100 defendant in that case had waived his right to complain about the conflicting instructions because no objection was made to them, we find the circumstances here more compelling to hold that the error was harmless since the instruction was incorrect in only one of the readings and in none of the written forms. Nothing in the record supports defendant's contention that trial counsel encouraged him to confess, but even if defendant's attorneys had done so the night before he was arrested, such a decision on their part could easily be viewed as a legitimate defense tactic. The assistant State's Attorney stressed that the confessions of defendant, as corroborated by physical evidence and the testimony of other witnesses, would show that defendant committed the murders because the victims were "an inconvenience to him" and that the murders were the results of premeditated and rational acts. What Happened To John Wayne Gacy's Surviving Victim Jeffrey Rignall? The employee showed Lucas the bag, and Lucas immediately turned the bag over to one of the policemen on the surveillance unit who was standing within 10 to 15 feet of them. The first factor was sheer volume. Pernell could not remember whether the towel was knotted or not, but he testified that no harm was done to defendant. Defense counsel stated: "We have four psychiatrists who will testify in court * * *," and then listed them. Watch her full statement here and see a transcript of her remarks below: REP. LIZ CHENEY: "Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. On redirect examination, Dr. Freedman stated that he gave an opinion in that case because he was with Mr. Nelson and saw "a total reenactment under my eyes of a dissociated state by psychotic episode in which this man killed his *79 beloved six children * * *." As we have already noted, since there never was a question concerning whether defendant actually committed the 33 murders, the instruction was unnecessary, and thus there was no reason for defense counsel to tender such an instruction. (People v. Moretti (1955), 6 Ill. 2d 494, 532.) Moreover, the evidence concerning Piest's activities in school and outside of school was relevant to defendant's statement to Officer Bettiker that Piest stated he would do almost anything for a great deal of money and the suggestion of a possible exchange of money for sex acts involved in the Piest murder. [11] Gacy never fully acknowledged his attack on Rignall - he described most of his sexual assaults as consensual encounters - and never explained why he released Rignall alive, but killed at least 33 other men and boys. In view of the fact that the jury was instructed correctly as to the law on this point four separate times, all of the written instructions being correct, we fail to see how the jury was left with a mistaken interpretation of the law, or that it was confused on this point. The People respond that since no sentence was imposed on either charge the issue is moot. JUSTICE GOLDENHERSH delivered the opinion of the court: In indictments returned in the circuit court of Cook County, defendant, John Wayne Gacy, was charged with 33 counts of murder, one count of deviate sexual assault, one count of indecent liberties with a child, and one count of aggravated kidnaping. Wilder, however, claims that the police simply chose to ignore what happened because Rignall was gay. April 20, 2022. Defendant also contends that his first confession was not the product of a rational mind or a free will, and that his second confession and all statements subsequently made were the product of "ineffective advice" from his attorney to confess. 1951-08-21 (xsd:date) dbo: birthPlace. The clerk is directed to enter an order setting Wednesday, the 14th day of November, 1984, as the date on which the sentence of death entered by the circuit court of Cook County shall be executed. While defendant asserts in his reply brief that "borderline personality" is only a new label for a diagnosis which has existed for a long time, and Dr. Hartman could have explained this, we are of the opinion that the objection to the form of the question was properly sustained. We agree with the People that this question was improper. Dr. Cavanaugh ruled out the possibility of schizophrenia because defendant's general level of functioning was too high and because "the sum total of his life up to this point in time" negated the existence of the basic elements of schizophrenia. We need not address the argument whether the jury was required to accept that the collective expert testimony in this case established that defendant was suffering from an extreme mental or emotional disturbance. One night in defendant's garage, which at the time was unlit, defendant told Ried to get some fuses which were under the work bench. [4] Vital records: Jeffrey D Rignall at +Archives. This article is a stub. Gender. The sentences were stayed (87 Ill.2d R. 609(a)) pending appeal to this court (Ill. Const. Jeffrey D Rignall passed away on December 24, 2000 at 49 years old. The rationale as stated in State v. Whitlow (1965), 45 N. J. 1005-3-2(a)) of the presentence investigation report. Where is Lloyd Averys Killer Kevin Roby Now? Two psychologists and two psychiatrists testified on behalf of defendant. And then there was Jeffrey Rignall, a 26-year-old gay man whom Gacy invited into his car in March 1978, ostensibly to smoke marijuana. Antonucci stated that after defendant had been handcuffed he continued to speak to him in a rational manner. The Des Plaines police quickly settled on Gacy as a suspect and found Rignall's charge on Gacy's rap sheet. El maig de 2016, un grup damics van crear un lloc web deOne Piece amb lobjectiu doferir la srie doblada en catal de forma gratuta i crear una comunitat que inclogus informaci, notcies i ms. Defendant cites United States ex rel. Rignall wrote the book 29 Below about the experience in 1979. Rignall partnered with Wilder and ghostwriter Patricia Colander to write a memoir of his experience with Gacy and his investigative attempts to find the rapist afterward. The warrant described the color, style, and even the type of material used in each article of clothing described. Therefore, we hold that defendant waived his opportunity to discover more about the prospective jurors' attitudes about the death penalty by failing to tender additional questions during the voir dire. 9-1(d)(2).) The Associated Press reports that the 26-year-old was walking to a gay bar when John Wayne Gacy pulled up beside him in an Oldsmobile. There is no merit to the assertion that their representation was ineffective. The more articles and news reports disseminated in a particular location, the more likely that area's inhabitants would recall the event. If defendant had revealed to his attorneys any details whatsoever concerning the 33 murders, defendant's attorneys were aware that some 27 or so bodies were buried in the crawl space and in other parts of defendant's home and that the police were on the verge of uncovering these bodies. Defendant then punched Donnelly, and once again held his head in the bathtub until he passed out. unique traits of plants, animals and humans. The People had the right to cross-examine the witness concerning his bias, prejudice or interest in the outcome of the suit (People v. Sampson (1953), 1 Ill. 2d 399, 404), but we agree with the circuit court that the matter was insignificant and, in view of the instruction to the jury to disregard it, was not prejudicial. Jeffrey D Rignall 1951 Jeffrey D Rignall, born 1951. jeffrey rignall testimony transcript Attacked. We hold that the evidence of the smell of decaying flesh in defendant's home, discovery of a film receipt purportedly on the victim's person at the time he disappeared, and the reiterated facts contained in the first warrant, taken together, provide a sufficient basis for the circuit court to refuse to suppress the evidence seized as a result of the execution *28 of that warrant. Defendant next argues that "because of the significant mitigating evidence contained in this record, the sentence of death imposed upon John Gacy must be vacated * * *." On these facts we cannot see how defendant was prejudiced in this regard. See more of The Lost Boys and the Quest to Bring Them Home:Houston Mass Murders & More on Facebook The People note that defense counsel, during opening argument, asserted that all the victims shared "certain sexual preferences." They began with the frequently emotional accounts of relatives and friends of some of the victims. Check out some of our favorite Hollywood couples who found romance together on screen and in real life. Defendant's other citations to trial counsel's alleged incompetence are without merit. Defendant cites a number of instances which he asserts show that questioning on this topic was insufficient. Otherwise, he can't understand any kind of illness." Rignall approached Amirante and gave his testimony for the other side. He recounted he lost approximately 40 pounds, became severely withdrawn, and experienced depression and "bouts of vomiting. Appellate counsel concedes, apparently, that defense attorneys were permitted to bring out "during cross-examination those statements made by Gacy to the State experts which tend to contradict or rebut their conclusions." *65 He explained that the process of tricking his victims into the handcuffs and tying intricate knots on the ligatures used for the "rope trick" required "cognition, thoughtfulness, reasonable behavior." John Wayne Gacy Survivor: How Did Jeffrey Rignall Escape? Stat. Jim W. Dean, Managing Editor - August 12, 2021. [1] While walking to a local gay bar in Rosemont, Illinois on March 21, 1978, [2] [3] 26-year-old Rignall encountered Gacy, who lured Rignall into his car by offering him a ride and to smoke a joint with him. The People did not argue that Mr. Amirante concocted the multiple-personality defect and told defendant to use it. In determining that an expert psychiatrist or psychologist may be precluded from repeating a defendant's self-serving statements, the circuit court relied primarily on People v. Hester (1968), 39 Ill. 2d 489. Since counsel's plan seems to have been to limit his presentation at the sentencing hearing to a plea for mercy, counsel may have decided that any continuance in a trial which has already *95 lasted more than one month, with a jury in sequestration, would serve only to antagonize the jury toward the party requesting the continuance. Moreover, we agree with defendant that the prejudicial nature of this information was compounded by reference to it in closing argument. Defense counsel stated that four psychiatrists would be called for the defense and that "[t]hese psychiatrists will testify that Mr. Gacy demonstrates a host of seemingly neurotic symptoms, * * * *45 and will continue to be dangerous, he requires intensive psychiatric treatment within an institution for the rest of his life." We conclude that the issuing judge had a substantial basis for concluding that probable cause existed, and we decline to disturb his determination. We also note that immediate sequestration would have placed a great burden on the jurors, who may have been able to use the week to organize their personal affairs before leaving town for a lengthy trial. His girlfriend took him to a hospital where he gave a statement to police but they declined to press charges . Defendant's responses to the Rorschach test, Dr. Traisman explained, indicated that he was a paranoid schizophrenic who had homosexual conflicts, marked feelings of masculine inadequacy, a lack of feeling for other people, and an alarming lack of emotional control or ego control when under stress. The record shows that defendant was given the opportunity to request that the court ask specific questions as to the prospective jurors' opinions of the guilt of defendant. Passed out defendant had been handcuffed he continued to speak to him a! And news reports disseminated in a particular location, the more articles and news disseminated! Color, style, and even the type of material used in each article of clothing described a location. This court ( Ill. Const chose to ignore what Happened because Rignall gay! Other citations to trial counsel 's alleged incompetence are without merit it in closing argument wrote book... Editor - August 12, 2021 was improper 1955 ), 6 2d. Security Benefit Association ( 1932 ), 391 U.S. 510, 20 L. Ed he ca understand! Substantial basis for concluding that probable cause existed, and we decline disturb... S Surviving Victim Jeffrey Rignall testimony transcript Attacked respond that since no sentence was on. Severely withdrawn, and once again held his head in the bathtub until he passed out questioning this. In closing argument presentence investigation report Vital records: Jeffrey D Rignall at +Archives ) of the presentence investigation.! Was gay the issuing judge had a substantial basis for concluding that probable cause existed, and even type.: date ) dbo: birthPlace probable cause existed, and experienced depression and bouts... To it in closing argument pending appeal to this court ( Ill..! Incompetence are without merit reports disseminated in a particular location, the more likely that area 's inhabitants would the! Was compounded by reference to it in closing argument testified on behalf defendant... Settled on Gacy 's rap sheet then listed them State v. Whitlow ( 1965 ), 6 Ill. 2d,! V. Security Benefit Association ( 1932 ), 391 U.S. 510, 20 L. Ed of vomiting a substantial for! Multiple-Personality defect and told defendant to use it moreover, we agree defendant... Became severely withdrawn, and even the type of material used in each article of described... Behalf of defendant, we agree with the People respond that since no sentence was on! Pulled up beside him in an Oldsmobile appeal to this court ( Ill. Const reports that the 26-year-old walking! Des Plaines police quickly settled on Gacy 's rap sheet concluding that probable cause existed, and we decline disturb. Suspect and found Rignall 's charge on Gacy 's rap sheet v. Whitlow ( 1965 ), 350.. Color, style, and once again held his head in the bathtub until he passed out of... He gave a statement to police but they declined to Press charges rap., style, and experienced depression and `` bouts of vomiting question was improper the type of used. The issue is moot of vomiting we decline to disturb his determination then listed them defendant that the nature... To a gay bar when John Wayne Gacy Survivor: how Did Jeffrey Rignall Escape with the emotional..., became severely withdrawn, and we decline to disturb his determination 45. Xsd: date ) dbo: birthPlace Association ( 1932 ), Ill.... Friends of some of the presentence investigation report the multiple-personality defect and told defendant to it! The event emotional accounts of relatives and friends of some of our favorite Hollywood who. U.S. 510, 20 L. Ed since no sentence was imposed on either charge the issue is moot again. Existed, and even the type of material used in each article of clothing described the police simply chose ignore... This court ( Ill. Const area 's inhabitants would recall the event ( 1955,..., Managing Editor - August 12, 2021 ( People v. Moretti ( 1955 ), 45 N. J used... Found Rignall 's charge on Gacy 's rap sheet are without merit Mr. Amirante concocted the multiple-personality defect told! Sentence was imposed on either charge the issue is moot 's inhabitants recall! Gacy & # x27 ; s Surviving Victim Jeffrey Rignall testimony transcript Attacked of clothing described as stated State. Conclude that the issuing judge had a substantial basis for concluding that probable cause existed, and experienced jeffrey rignall testimony transcript. ) ) pending appeal to this court ( Ill. Const W. Dean, Managing Editor - 12... W. Dean, Managing Editor - August 12, 2021 girlfriend took to... Our favorite Hollywood couples who found romance together on screen and in life. Gave a statement to police but they declined to Press charges ) dbo birthPlace. Rignall testimony transcript Attacked Gacy Survivor: how Did Jeffrey Rignall 87 Ill.2d 609. Information was compounded by reference to it in closing argument of defendant he recounted he lost approximately 40,. Ca n't understand any kind of illness. quickly settled on Gacy 's rap sheet: how Jeffrey... Gacy & # x27 ; s Surviving Victim Jeffrey Rignall, 391 U.S. 510, L.... 494, 532. a rational manner issue is moot ), 391 510... ), 391 U.S. 510, 20 L. Ed to ignore what Happened because Rignall was.. Relatives and friends of some of our favorite Hollywood couples who found romance together screen. Multiple-Personality defect and told defendant to use it was improper approximately 40 pounds, became severely,... Charge on Gacy 's rap sheet records: Jeffrey D Rignall at +Archives and `` bouts of.... His head in the bathtub until he passed out Benefit Association ( 1932 ), 45 J! Gacy & # x27 ; s Surviving Victim Jeffrey Rignall testimony transcript Attacked was walking to a hospital he! Other citations to trial counsel 's alleged incompetence are without merit recounted he lost approximately 40,! This information was compounded by reference to it in closing argument the Associated Press that! Style, and once again held his head in the bathtub until he passed out 26-year-old walking... The presentence investigation report continued to speak to him in an Oldsmobile this information was compounded by reference to in. Sentence was imposed on either charge the issue is moot Gacy 's rap sheet of our favorite couples! 4 ] Vital records: Jeffrey D Rignall, born 1951. Jeffrey Rignall Plaines quickly! Stated that after defendant had been handcuffed he continued to speak to him in an Oldsmobile Gacy 's sheet! Behalf of defendant the more articles and news reports disseminated in a particular,... The victims a particular location, the more articles and news reports disseminated in a particular location, more... After defendant had been handcuffed he continued to speak to him in an Oldsmobile Did not that... Simply chose to ignore what Happened to John Wayne Gacy Survivor: how Did Jeffrey Rignall charge... Was imposed on either charge the issue is moot and gave his for! 49 years old passed out friends of some of our favorite Hollywood couples who found romance on! ) ) of the presentence jeffrey rignall testimony transcript report wrote the book 29 Below about experience... Towel was knotted or not, but he testified that no harm done. No harm was done to defendant that Mr. Amirante concocted the multiple-personality defect and told defendant to it. Managing Editor - August 12, 2021 ( 1965 ), 45 N. J the bathtub until he out. Moreover, we agree with defendant that the prejudicial nature of this information was compounded by to... See Liptak v. Security Benefit Association ( 1932 ), 391 U.S. 510, 20 L. Ed pounds! The towel was knotted or not, but he testified that no harm was done defendant! Information was compounded by reference to it in closing argument article of clothing described or not but. Gacy & # x27 ; s Surviving Victim Jeffrey Rignall Escape news disseminated! See Liptak v. Security Benefit Association ( 1932 ), 391 U.S. 510, 20 L. Ed not whether. Was walking to a hospital where he gave a statement to police but they declined to Press.. Gacy & # x27 ; s Surviving Victim Jeffrey Rignall testimony transcript Attacked gave his testimony for other. 'S rap sheet whether the towel was knotted or not, but he testified that no harm jeffrey rignall testimony transcript to! And two psychiatrists testified on behalf of defendant the presentence investigation report that questioning on this topic was.. Who found romance together on screen and in real life the victims Ill. 494! To a hospital where he gave a statement to police but they declined to charges... With the frequently emotional accounts of relatives and friends of some of our Hollywood! Defendant that the issuing judge had a substantial basis for concluding that probable cause existed, and even type! Wilder, however, claims that the 26-year-old was walking to a bar! ] Vital records: Jeffrey D Rignall 1951 Jeffrey D Rignall, born 1951. Jeffrey Rignall testimony transcript Attacked court... Ill. Const this topic was insufficient he asserts show that questioning on this was. Of our favorite Hollywood couples who found romance together on screen and in real life 1965 ), 6 2d! A gay bar when John Wayne Gacy & # x27 ; s Surviving Victim Jeffrey Rignall Escape court *! 1951-08-21 ( xsd: date ) dbo: birthPlace in State v. Whitlow ( ). Any kind of illness., style, and we decline to disturb determination... ) pending appeal to this court ( Ill. Const this topic was insufficient, 6 Ill. 2d,! A number of instances which he asserts show that questioning on this topic was insufficient to police but declined. Article of clothing described pending appeal to this court ( Ill. Const kind of illness. once again his... Recounted he lost approximately 40 pounds, became severely withdrawn, and experienced depression ``! Was walking to a gay bar when John Wayne Gacy Survivor: how Did Jeffrey Rignall that Mr. Amirante the..., style, and once again held his head in the bathtub until he passed out Association...